Platform Work in China with Lin Zhang

Show notes

About the Guest Lin Zhang is an associate professor of communication at the University of New Hampshire and the author of The Labour of Reinvention: Entrepreneurship in the New Chinese Digital Economy (2023). Her research examines digital platforms, labor, entrepreneurship, and economic change in China and other contexts.

Summary
Zhang describes digital platforms as algorithmically programmed infrastructures that enable interactions and transactions, while emphasizing that “platform” is also a contested concept shaped by business rhetoric and academic inquiry. She recounts how her research began with online culture in China and developed into ethnographic studies of work, entrepreneurship, and platformization, including rural e-commerce, innovation spaces, and cross-border reselling.

The discussion examines limits in Silicon Valley-centered accounts of platform capitalism. Zhang highlights the role of families and small-scale, often informal production in platform economies, including the gendered labor associated with Chinese e-commerce villages. She also discusses how comparative research across China, India, Japan, and the Gulf region can broaden platform studies, while noting tensions between locally grounded research and theories that travel across settings.

Zhang argues that China’s big-tech governance cannot be reduced to a simple opposition between authoritarian control and market liberalism. Using Alibaba as a case, she describes a fragmented state with central and local governments that may have different priorities. Government approaches have shifted over time, from supporting platform growth to tighter regulation and later a softer stance, while local officials have also worked with companies to advance economic and policy goals.

Her current work examines how AI and data infrastructures are reshaping agriculture, governance, and rural life in China, as well as a book project on the movement of knowledge, talent, capital, and policy in the Chinese and global biotechnology industries.

Show transcript

Speaker0: Welcome to another episode of the Talking About Platforms podcast.

Speaker0: My name is Philipp Meyer and I am here recording in Berlin with my regular co-host

Speaker0: Volker Stocker. Hi, Volker.

Speaker2: Hi, Philipp. Can't wait for today's podcast episode.

Speaker0: And as always, we have an exciting guest. Our guest for today is Lin Chiang.

Speaker0: Lin is an associate professor of communication at the University of New Hampshire,

Speaker0: and the author of the highly acclaimed 2023 book The Labour of Reinvention Entrepreneurship

Speaker0: in the New Chinese Digital Economy.

Speaker0: Lin, welcome to the podcast.

Speaker1: Thank you for having me on the show.

Speaker0: Then we and all the listeners notice and maybe they're getting slightly tired

Speaker0: from me mentioning this every time but i still have to,

Speaker0: and we have a recurring opening question to uh to every guest and it's a two-part

Speaker0: question and the first part is,

Speaker0: what is a digital platform to you we ask this question because the definitions

Speaker0: of digital platforms are as diverse as our guests are usually.

Speaker0: So what is a digital platform to you? And maybe a bit on a personal note,

Speaker0: how did you end up studying digital platforms?

Speaker1: Yeah, I think these two are actually very important questions.

Speaker1: And I really enjoyed the listening to other people's answers on your show as well.

Speaker1: So for me, in the narrow sense of the song concept, platform refer to,

Speaker1: you know, platforms, right?

Speaker1: So I see it as a kind of algorithmically programmed and also digitally configured

Speaker1: infrastructure that needed interactions and transactions of various agents.

Speaker1: Some of the most prominent digital platforms that we use frequently today also

Speaker1: happen to be publicistic, monopolistic, multinational firms.

Speaker1: But there are also other less visible, more local, and sometimes even non-profit

Speaker1: oriented digital platforms out there. However,

Speaker1: I want to say that in the broader sense of a term platform, if we see it as

Speaker1: a kind of interdisciplinary field of study, that of platform studies,

Speaker1: the above definition, I think, confining to digital platforms,

Speaker1: you know, not to mention all these kind of prominent big tech firms can be sometimes

Speaker1: is constraining and also problematic.

Speaker1: So the field itself, I would say, actually emerged in the past two decades or

Speaker1: so as a kind of collective, but also kind of fragmented effort to understand

Speaker1: and analyze the rest of digital platforms,

Speaker1: not just as a kind of a materialization of the wave of new technology,

Speaker1: such as multi-sided digital platforms.

Speaker1: I remember the 4G and 5G mobile technologies was mentioned a lot,

Speaker1: and now increasingly AI and AI agents.

Speaker1: So, but it's also, for me, it's a discursive construction.

Speaker1: It's a management and rhetorical buzz, in a sense, popularized,

Speaker1: like many tech buzz work today by Silicon Valley, Wall Street Forces,

Speaker1: which subsequently has been kind of prioritizing over the world, right?

Speaker1: So as I traced and summarized, you guys probably

Speaker1: Read my Asian platform capitalism special issue introductory essay,

Speaker1: and there has been actually many efforts among scholars of various backgrounds who historicize

Speaker1: to deconstruct and reconstruct what platform is.

Speaker1: For example, my colleague Mark Stenberg traced the genealogy of platforms as

Speaker1: management ideas, not to Silicon Valley, but actually to Japanese management theories.

Speaker1: For example, to Toyotaism in the 80s and Japanese mobile internet system iMode in the 90s and 2000s.

Speaker1: And also the Canada-based, another Canada-based scholar, Eliza Lim,

Speaker1: she situated platform theory alongside operations of East Indian Company in

Speaker1: Malaysia to kind of expose all continuities in capitalist governance,

Speaker1: dispossession, and also management, which,

Speaker1: According to her, is only intensified and scaled through this kind of transnational

Speaker1: digital platforms today.

Speaker1: So in this regard, I agree very much with what Thomas Epperly and Jussi Perica

Speaker1: said in their 2018 article that, you know, we, you know,

Speaker1: in the process of doing basically platform studies, we construct a uniform platform, right?

Speaker1: So in a way, I find this kind of Foucaultian approach to platform narrative

Speaker1: useful here in underlying the kind of constructed nature and also

Speaker1: underlying motives, whether it's on the part of Silicon Valley venture capitalists

Speaker1: and tech entrepreneurs building a new commercial bus, or as scholars trying

Speaker1: to really pass through these transformations

Speaker1: and also make interventions from our own

Speaker1: various political vantage points.

Speaker1: But I understand, based on my previous conversation with people, that this

Speaker1: can also be frustrating, especially for younger generations of scholars really wanting to

Speaker1: enter into and also position themselves vis-a-vis existing conversations and

Speaker1: debates when these conversations are getting increasingly diffused,

Speaker1: interdisciplinary, and international.

Speaker1: But I think this is true, I would say, for any prominent narrative and discourse and field of study,

Speaker1: thinking of neoliberalism, for example, in the past and increasingly artificial

Speaker1: intelligence, I think it's also emerging as encompassing many different things.

Speaker1: So, the second part of your question, how do I end up studying platforms?

Speaker1: So, I started out studying digital platforms actually as a grad student in the

Speaker1: late 2000s and early 2010s.

Speaker1: At the beginning, I was not consciously engaging with platform studies per se.

Speaker1: So, from the very beginning, I have been interested in the role of internet

Speaker1: as other digital technologies and sciences in transforming, in particular Chinese society.

Speaker1: That's where I came from.

Speaker1: And itself is a rising industrial and technological power.

Speaker1: So a prominent discourse I remember in the late 2000s was whether the internet

Speaker1: could democratize China.

Speaker1: So especially with the rise of so-called Web 2.0 and user generated content at that time.

Speaker1: And as a young researcher, I was actually fascinated at the time by online user-generated

Speaker1: Spoofing culture called 饿gao in Chinese, and also online gaming culture.

Speaker1: At that time, it was still so-called MMORPGs, the massive multiplayer games,

Speaker1: if you remember, the World of Warcraft and all that.

Speaker1: But the more ethnographic research I did, the more acutely I became aware of

Speaker1: the kind of broader transformations taking place in terms of organization for

Speaker1: labor, consumption, and also business models underpinning the kind of

Speaker1: Simulating democratizing existence of digital participatory culture,

Speaker1: which is another kind of prominent discourse at that time.

Speaker1: So this early interest in exploring the changing nature of work and labor,

Speaker1: the collapsing distinction between work and play, and also labor and entrepreneurship,

Speaker1: led me to explore various industries and groups of people

Speaker1: From rural handicraft e-commerce in Chinese villages,

Speaker1: urban entrepreneurial culture, emerging innovation spaces, like all these kind of

Speaker1: innovation clusters, incubators, co-working, and maker spaces in major Chinese cities like Beijing,

Speaker1: to women-dominated transnational reselling micro-ecomers entrepreneurship called

Speaker1: Daigo in Chinese that actually resell Western luxury and other products back to China.

Speaker1: So all this eventually criticized into, you mentioned at the beginning,

Speaker1: my first monograph, The Labor of Reinvention, Entrepreneurship in the Neo-Chinese Digital Economy.

Speaker1: Which was published by the Columbia University Press in 2023,

Speaker1: And the book was not really about digital platforms, I would say,

Speaker1: but focusing more on entrepreneurial labor behind the remaking of selves,

Speaker1: economy and nation and their platformization and digitalization since 2008.

Speaker1: As China transitioned from factory of the world to a tech innovator,

Speaker1: and in particular, I deployed the concept of reinvention to emphasize the prominent roles.

Speaker1: But also, I think, at that time, at least, often neglected

Speaker1: roles played by state and family, in mediating the kind of multi-level transformations

Speaker1: and the spatial-temperal specific contradictions generated

Speaker1: By such reinvention.

Speaker1: And it was in the process of revising this book from my dissertation in late

Speaker1: 2010s and early in 2020s that I encountered actually the debate,

Speaker1: seriously encountered about digital platforms.

Speaker1: So the debate was so prominent and relevant to my research. At that time,

Speaker1: I had really had to precision myself in relation to it in a way.

Speaker1: So as you can imagine, I find at that time the academic conversations about

Speaker1: platforms to be both productive and constraining.

Speaker1: So it was productive in the sense that established researchers

Speaker1: writing about platforms had provided me some very useful theoretical languages

Speaker1: to understand what's new about digital platforms, such as

Speaker1: data centrality, algorithmic multi-sided mediation, and also,

Speaker1: you know, the discourse of kind of arbitrating of big tech firms

Speaker1: as, you know, just a neutral intermediary, some early wave of research.

Speaker1: And also, I have to say that platform study also provided a basis for us researchers

Speaker1: working in different geographical contexts.

Speaker1: In the U.S., it's often referred to as area studies, the silos of area studies,

Speaker1: to come together to formulate conversations, identify points of comparison.

Speaker1: But it's also frustrating in the sense that most often cited papers and books

Speaker1: at that time were all abstracted from Silicon Valley platforms as they have

Speaker1: been expanding around the world.

Speaker1: From where I stood, I see a lot of gaps, both theoretically and empirically, in platform studies.

Speaker1: And I think my effort to close these gaps, my humble effort to do that,

Speaker1: through that, I found intellectual community, and in particular,

Speaker1: as you mentioned in our previous emails, to kind of theorize and pluralize platform capitalism with NS.

Speaker1: Yeah, so that's kind of an answer to the question you mentioned.

Speaker1: I hope that's kind of useful, but it does help me to kind of think about what I did.

Speaker0: No, no, totally, totally. Thank you so much for elaborating and sharing this.

Speaker0: Let me directly jump in and pick up the platform capitalism term that you just mentioned.

Speaker0: And from the story that you just shared,

Speaker0: In my memory, thinking about the origin of the platform capitalism term,

Speaker0: I think it was 2016. And I think.

Speaker0: The general framing was that following the financial crisis in 2008 and then

Speaker0: having companies developing like Uber, Airbnb.

Speaker0: Be um with the like in the beginning these strong intentions that also the platforms

Speaker0: from the dot-com boom like ebay and and the likes in the beginning had and the story was,

Speaker0: sharing free making or using resources that are already there in a more efficient

Speaker0: way resources could also be then labor and i think in 2014 2016 the field.

Speaker0: Let's say separated in in different directions and one was heading towards this

Speaker0: we have a platform revolution to come with a very like positive narrative,

Speaker0: and then the other one i think this is a little bit more in my opinion was a

Speaker0: little bit more in my opinion the um,

Speaker0: the platform capitalism field that was putting more emphasis on the extraction of value and,

Speaker0: the surveillance the growing surveillance apparatus that that companies developed

Speaker0: with more scale and the like the power asymmetry that developed with,

Speaker0: platforms building more scale right and and so i think this is then how kind of,

Speaker0: different perspectives look looked at a at a very similar development,

Speaker0: But I think coming back to the beginning, from the 2008 dot-com boom,

Speaker0: I think one of the arguments why the platforms became so successful also in the West and.

Speaker0: In Silicon Valley was as a replacement for more traditional manufacturing-driven

Speaker0: value creation industries.

Speaker0: Or other traditional industries like banking, like pharma. So,

Speaker0: the entrepreneurs and the innovators were looking into the digital space and

Speaker0: then found the digital platform,

Speaker0: as a mean to building new business models.

Speaker0: So this is the platform capitalism framing that I know.

Speaker0: Now you tell me that my framework for understanding platform capitalism falls

Speaker0: a bit short and that I should extend my perspective,

Speaker0: with the plurality that platform capitalism can bring.

Speaker0: So Lin, please explain what my framework of understanding is missing.

Speaker1: Yeah, thank you so much for kind of summarizing and reflecting on,

Speaker1: you know, what that framework is, which I find to be very useful.

Speaker1: I remember in 2016, 17, when I read Nick Senechek's book at that time,

Speaker1: I find it to be really helpful for me to understand platform in a kind of more

Speaker1: micro political non-exense.

Speaker1: And previous, I think before that, a lot of the research focused more on affordances

Speaker1: and, you know, like the material shift, the material turn in Internet studies.

Speaker1: And I feel like the platform capitalism framework was at that time

Speaker1: kind of a useful antidote to the kind of very optimistic framing of that,

Speaker1: as I mentioned, popularized by Silicon Valley and Wall Street.

Speaker1: So that's also the conversation I entered at that time.

Speaker1: But I also feel like a lot of the discussion at that time was built on this

Speaker1: kind of transatlantic, Wall Street, New York, Silicon Valley, London dynamics,

Speaker1: where we talk about after the 2008 global financial crisis, what happened, right?

Speaker1: And also the kind of replacement, as you mentioned, of manufacturing.

Speaker1: But if you go beyond, right, the kind of transatlantic connections,

Speaker1: You'll see sort of different dynamics.

Speaker1: So as I try to theorize from my field work in rural, urban, and transnational China, I came to see,

Speaker1: I would, you know, summarize now as two prominent blind spots in the existing

Speaker1: research into, at that time, into platform capitalism.

Speaker1: One, I think it's the role played by families in mediating platform labor and production.

Speaker1: And so in addition to my 2023 book, I try to confront really these issues in three articles.

Speaker1: One is my 2018 piece titled When Platform Capitalism Meets Petty Capitalism

Speaker1: in China, in which I try to kind of situate the rise of e-commerce platforms

Speaker1: like Alibaba in the history of Chinese petty capitalist economy.

Speaker1: Right. So drawing on historical anthropologists like Hill Gates,

Speaker1: I show how the Chinese platform economy has been crafted onto,

Speaker1: right, rather than kind of replacing.

Speaker1: And it's also reshaping in a way the petty capitalist tradition,

Speaker1: often taking the form of small scale family based, a flexible regime of production

Speaker1: and a lot of time still in the countryside in rural China.

Speaker1: But I did not have enough space in that article to really elaborate on what

Speaker1: I see as a kind of a new gender division of labor emerging in all these kind

Speaker1: of Taobao or e-commerce villages in which I did my ethnographic research

Speaker1: as well as their implications for understanding rural-urban

Speaker1: divide and gender inequalities in China and this was actually featured

Speaker1: essentially in my 2021 piece in which I actually developed the concept of the

Speaker1: quote-unquote platformized family production.

Speaker1: And in 2024, as I revisited these

Speaker1: e-commerce villages after COVID-19, I wrote a simple piece titled A Social Reproductive

Speaker1: Perspective into Rural E-Commerce and Internet History in China,

Speaker1: in which I actually discussed the kind of impending social reproductive crisis

Speaker1: in rural China, which is threatening the kind of sustainability of the previously

Speaker1: platformized family production that I mapped out with issues like population

Speaker1: aging, for example, real estate deaths, and the evaluation of care, work, and labor.

Speaker1: So another blind spot from the platform capitalism literature at that time,

Speaker1: I think, regards the rule of state,

Speaker1: which I could talk more in depth vis-a-vis China later because I know you're

Speaker1: interested in the Chinese regime of big tech governance.

Speaker1: But before that, I want to say that I'm very lucky to have found a kind of like-minded

Speaker1: collaborators who actually helped me to see that China is far from unique.

Speaker1: And my interventions into platforms that have kind of wider resonances among

Speaker1: many scholars trying to think and write about platform cultures,

Speaker1: economy, beyond that of Silicon Valley.

Speaker1: For example, with Mark Stenberg and Rahul Mukherjee, we argued for a kind of

Speaker1: polarization of platform capitalism framework based on research in Japan,

Speaker1: China, and India, respectively.

Speaker1: And later, Hattam, Al-Hibri, and Joe Khalil, both of whom wrote extensively

Speaker1: about media and platforms in the Gulf region, joined our conversation.

Speaker1: So in thinking and writing along with them, as well as curating a double special

Speaker1: issue in social media plus society on

Speaker1: Reimagination in platform capitalism in collaboration with Eileen Yuan.

Speaker1: So I have to really come to appreciate even more the kind of theoretical value

Speaker1: of theorizing from silicon elsewhere, just to borrow a term from Andrea Polio's

Speaker1: really excellent new work.

Speaker1: So, for example, to be more specific here, well, until recently,

Speaker1: the Silicon Valley-centric discourse of platform capitalism emphasized market-led

Speaker1: platform growth and also a kind of detached, passive state.

Speaker1: We see in our various contexts the importance of intrastate and trans-state

Speaker1: dynamics mediated by connected firms like SoftBank, for example,

Speaker1: informing not just capital connections, but also

Speaker1: reforming regions themselves.

Speaker1: And also in understanding platform capitalism as context dependent and also

Speaker1: historical contingent, we have mapped out the multifaceted roles of state, for example,

Speaker1: as regulators, as financiers, as ecosystem builders, which is,

Speaker1: I think, especially true in so-called late developing countries trying to play

Speaker1: catch up, quote unquote.

Speaker1: And through collaboration, I have also come to appreciate the various ways in which,

Speaker1: and sometimes the contradictory politics of incorporating family-based,

Speaker1: petty capitalist, informal economy into global platform capitalism,

Speaker1: you know, what happened beyond China in the context.

Speaker1: So if we theorize from the U.S. and Western Europe, maybe to a lesser extent,

Speaker1: platform capitalism may feel like informatizing or already informatized and

Speaker1: well-protected labor force into precarious labor.

Speaker1: But experiences, for example, in India, in China, in Indonesia,

Speaker1: just to name a few, reveal different trajectories of platformization in which

Speaker1: formalized labor regime has not been well established.

Speaker1: Instead of a single national market. A market can be actually highly fragmented

Speaker1: and multi-layered in these places.

Speaker1: And platformization as a process actually, you know, challenge,

Speaker1: even challenge the kind of varied dichotomy between what is formal and what

Speaker1: is informal in these kind of contexts,

Speaker1: Which, you know, Rahu Mukherjee, you know, argued a lot about that in the India context.

Speaker1: So in the process of writing collaboratively

Speaker1: and also curating special issues on digital platforms, I have also come to feel

Speaker1: more acutely the kind of tensions between all these kind of various approaches.

Speaker1: I actually mapped these tensions out in my introduction to the Asian platform

Speaker1: capital special issue in four aspects, as I mentioned, of the tensions between

Speaker1: technological affordances and the cultural specificities.

Speaker1: You know, methodological localism has value, but how do we channel that towards

Speaker1: theoretical theory building, right? And also, we already mentioned the dynamic

Speaker1: between state and transnationalism.

Speaker1: And also in the specific context between inter-Asia references and a kind of,

Speaker1: I think, restructuring power inequalities that's out there even within the region itself.

Speaker1: So I think it's true passing through and struggling with this productive tensions

Speaker1: in our own research and writing about platforms that we have come to shape in

Speaker1: a cacophonous way, maybe not a kind of unified way,

Speaker1: the very interdisciplinary field of platform studies

Speaker1: today. Yeah.

Speaker2: Thank you so much. That's basically a perfect point to dig a bit deeper,

Speaker2: I guess, and focusing on your recent work published in the Social Media and

Speaker2: Society Journal in 2025.

Speaker2: And you mentioned a special issue introduction you wrote with Elaine Yuan,

Speaker2: where you just mentioned it, right? You identify these productive tensions between

Speaker2: what I really like the term methodological localism and theory building.

Speaker2: You structure this, I think, across several. You mentioned like four aspects.

Speaker2: Which basically structured the special issue. So on the one hand,

Speaker2: as you mentioned, there is a lot of value, obviously, in deep, let's say,

Speaker2: context-aware, context-sensitive studies that take the specificities of national

Speaker2: or subnational settings very seriously.

Speaker2: For example, regulatory culture of a given province or region.

Speaker2: On the other hand, there's a risk that staying local means we never build a

Speaker2: kind of comparative, connective, universal, near-universal theory that can travel across contexts.

Speaker2: In your paper, the other paper I want to refer to, From Platform Capitalism to Digital China,

Speaker2: I think you ask more or less researchers to think beyond individual case studies

Speaker2: toward frameworks that can capture the temporal and spatial dynamics of platforms. So,

Speaker2: Does these tensions or trade-offs between methodological localism and broader

Speaker2: theory-building mean in practice for the next generation of platform researchers?

Speaker2: And what kinds of, we mentioned this a bit, but what kinds of vantage points, partnerships,

Speaker2: research designs do we need to cultivate to get towards a genuine pluralism

Speaker2: and diversity of perspectives?

Speaker2: One that does not simply add to non-Western case studies, to Western theoretical

Speaker2: frameworks, but rather transforms the conceptual scope, maybe,

Speaker2: and the vocabulary we use.

Speaker2: I know that's a big question, but I think we're keen on learning more and we have time.

Speaker1: Yeah, I think that's a good question. I think, actually, I think it's already happening.

Speaker1: And, for example, me being situated in China studies, for example,

Speaker1: like scholars working in different, like, for example, European contexts,

Speaker1: and we, you know, basically decided

Speaker1: Try not to just theorize from Silicon Valley and apply these theories to our

Speaker1: own context, but try to really look at temporal spatial specificity and abstract from our own writing.

Speaker1: And then in the process of, you know, writing about these specificities in collaboration

Speaker1: with each other, right? So we would arrive at some kind of higher level,

Speaker1: as you mentioned, theorization.

Speaker1: And previously I mentioned about state and families are something that I think

Speaker1: if you think more in social science terms, these are kind of important variables,

Speaker1: right, so that we can identify that we felt like we're missing the general kind

Speaker1: of production of theories in platforms.

Speaker1: And then we also try to be really specific in making out all these different

Speaker1: dynamics and how it works in different settings.

Speaker1: And I think especially European scholars, I think, are very good at maybe with

Speaker1: the support of, you know, fundings like ERC fundings, are very good at establishing,

Speaker1: you know, all these kind of platforms for people to meet together,

Speaker1: right, to have conversations and publish special issues and,

Speaker1: you know, feature all these kind of

Speaker1: Various voices, right? So I do feel like, you know, that's already happening

Speaker1: in a way. Like platform studies today is very different from a decade ago.

Speaker1: But there's definitely space in that direction for us to, you know,

Speaker1: work together and continue the kind of good work that we'll be doing.

Speaker2: May I follow up here? Because I'm an economist by background,

Speaker2: right? And I'm a typical economist because I work with engineers and computer

Speaker2: scientists and lawyers and social scientists for a long time.

Speaker2: But I sometimes feel like you mentioned collaboration. Where do you see interdisciplinarity true?

Speaker2: Interdisciplinarity situated there. Where do you see, like, do you see also

Speaker2: we are basically getting there well?

Speaker2: Or do you see, like, cross-geographical knowledge transfer and perspectives

Speaker2: to bring these together in collaborations is what we're good at.

Speaker2: But does this apply also across disciplinary silos?

Speaker1: Yeah, that's a good question.

Speaker1: I think, yeah, so it's also, it's a larger question about how,

Speaker1: you know, academic institution works, about how evaluation standards works.

Speaker1: So I actually, I find a lot of challenges actually trying to publish, for example, you know,

Speaker1: in some of the established academic journals when I want to,

Speaker1: for example, bring cultural national specificity in the conversation to publish

Speaker1: in, for example, more social science driven

Speaker1: Communication studies journals. Right.

Speaker1: So definitely, I think, you know, each discipline has their different kind of

Speaker1: historical sense of what matters. Right. So the big questions.

Speaker1: But that, you know, didn't really stop me from trying to, you know,

Speaker1: read about also in, you know, management studies, for example,

Speaker1: in economics, in history, in cultural studies.

Speaker1: In China studies, in Asian studies, right, try to really, in my own work,

Speaker1: You know, really fusing all these ideas together.

Speaker1: But I acknowledge that it's not easy to do that institutionally,

Speaker1: right, and to navigate that terrain of publication, of getting recognized,

Speaker1: especially for a younger scholar. I think it's not easy.

Speaker1: But I think that also means that, you know, like what I see innovation is not,

Speaker1: you know, inventing things out of thin air, but rather bringing all this kind

Speaker1: of different ideas from different

Speaker1: disciplines, different geographical regions, for example, together, right?

Speaker1: Different temporal, temporalities, right? So historicizing and all that.

Speaker1: So I see it's not easy, you know, but also that's what is productive,

Speaker1: what is innovative, and what is exciting about this kind of industry.

Speaker1: Interdisciplinary field. But I wouldn't say it's easy.

Speaker1: And I do see, you know, I do think that working together, maybe we could,

Speaker1: you know, do more to open up each of our own field to have better conversations

Speaker1: with each other with our different focuses.

Speaker1: Right. I don't know if that'll address your question.

Speaker2: No, absolutely, absolutely. I just wanted to get your insight here.

Speaker2: And this is just a shout out, of course, also to Philip and Daniel and Thomas for

Speaker2: creating this platform here, which I think is trying to establish a forum,

Speaker2: a platform to talk about platforms across these boundaries.

Speaker1: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. The very, very valuable work that you guys are doing.

Speaker0: I might have to cut this, otherwise it's too much for me. No, thank you so much.

Speaker0: And let's come to the to the second topic you already uh mentioned that in in

Speaker0: the beginning that i would like to or we would like to talk about,

Speaker0: and it's the uh let's say big tech regulation like the special circumstances

Speaker0: that we have in uh in china the examples you mentioned,

Speaker0: during the the topic we discussed before the the platform capitalisms um you mentioned india,

Speaker0: japan china these are like the three big regions in in asia that that i can

Speaker0: remember and when i read your your work i thought,

Speaker0: about a um a graphic that i saw multiple times,

Speaker0: and that shows like the united states with these bubbles these big like bubbles

Speaker0: with the monetary value of the valuations of the companies the big platforms

Speaker0: the big platform company value bubbles and then you,

Speaker0: they showed i think china or asia in as a as a combined region with the alibaba

Speaker0: and the tencents and the baidu,

Speaker0: and then there was a very very tiny set of bubbles and the headline was europe

Speaker0: there are very few and platform companies coming from,

Speaker0: uh from europe and when i when i think back about.

Speaker0: Let's say pre-Silicon Valley platform expansion into Germany then I remember that,

Speaker0: and I think Volker remembers that too and there were some let's say local alternatives

Speaker0: that that grew here in the field of social networks mobility,

Speaker0: so there were there were some some alternatives popping up And some are still there.

Speaker0: But at some point, I think, and that might be true across Europe,

Speaker0: in addition to another set of reasons,

Speaker0: the local governments decided to rather regulate,

Speaker0: American platforms instead of finding or changing regulation to promote,

Speaker0: let's say, local alternatives or a combined European market.

Speaker0: Volker is laughing at me.

Speaker2: You're making me mention the Draghi report again. This might be my thing every episode.

Speaker0: Right. So I think this is,

Speaker0: where we are at right now. I think we have also some kind of localism,

Speaker0: but it is more like a locally regulated version.

Speaker0: One example is Uber. So for example, here in Berlin, You can use Uber,

Speaker0: you can also use a German alternative and I think one alternative from Lithuania.

Speaker0: These are the mobility or mobility on demand platform alternatives.

Speaker0: But you don't have it as you have it in the US with private individuals offering

Speaker0: rides, because this is not compliant with German labor laws.

Speaker0: But you have companies, so the drivers, every driver has to have a license,

Speaker0: every driver must be employed by a company offering the service.

Speaker0: So it is like the Uber platform, but with the local flavor.

Speaker0: Now, long story short, we'd like to talk about the local flavors.

Speaker0: That you study in China. And also one thing I remembered was that somewhere between 2020 and 2023,

Speaker0: there were these headlines all over the news about the Chinese state fining

Speaker0: Alibaba and halting the Ant Group IPO.

Speaker0: And I think the media framing that I read was this authoritarian state now finally

Speaker0: cracking down their big tech giants because they became too powerful.

Speaker0: So this was the framing at the time.

Speaker0: Now, coming from this long introduction, talking a bit about the localism and

Speaker0: local flavors and this type of the state versus the big tech framing in China,

Speaker0: please help me understand your perspective a bit better.

Speaker1: Yeah, thank you for sharing about localism, the experience in Germany and also

Speaker1: Europe. Actually, as you spoke, it gave me new inspiration to think about what

Speaker1: is that exactly different. In a sense, I think…

Speaker1: in a way that both China and, you know, like China really had similar problems

Speaker1: of, you know, like in the European context,

Speaker1: the market, you know, I think what sets China different from maybe some of European

Speaker1: countries, China has a bigger market in a sense, but European Union as a whole

Speaker1: also has a big market, right?

Speaker1: And I think the kind of trans-state inter-state relationship is probably what

Speaker1: the European market has to really work out to come to a kind of

Speaker1: Consensus how to sustain across Europe to build up, you know, their own

Speaker1: Market to sustain the platform economy. And I think this kind of also speaks

Speaker1: to my article in a way that China is not as unified as many people think.

Speaker1: It's also fragmented, but not in a different sense as the European EU market.

Speaker1: So in this particular article, 2025, titled Market in a Fragmented state,

Speaker1: the fragmentation is in the title, Alibaba, the Chinese government regime of big techs.

Speaker1: I try to look at the kind of evolution of Chinese big tech companies like Alibaba,

Speaker1: specifically because I did a lot of empirical research on it over years.

Speaker1: From its founding in the late 1990s, at that time, right, so a lot of,

Speaker1: you know, American Silicon Valley-based platforms similar to what

Speaker1: you described was making new roles into China, eBay, Amazon, and all that.

Speaker1: And to basically the current moment where we have parallel ecosystem,

Speaker1: right, so the Chinese ones and the U.S. ones in a way.

Speaker1: So in looking at that history through Alibaba, I try to contest a kind of binary

Speaker1: understanding of Chinese-based relationships to its big tech platforms as either

Speaker1: authoritarian, anti-market, a big brother,

Speaker1: Looking at you, cracking you down, or a kind of statist, a neoliberal collaborator.

Speaker1: I think neither of them is true.

Speaker1: Simplified is true.

Speaker1: So to do that, I actually went back into Chinese economic history and political literature to

Speaker1: build up my analytic of marketing in a fragmented state

Speaker1: to historicize and conceptualize this kind of evolving relations between Chinese

Speaker1: big tech platforms and China's powerful, but also very pragmatic, adaptive,

Speaker1: And at the same time, highly fragmented polity.

Speaker1: So as an authoritarian state seeking to maintain legitimacy without the mechanism

Speaker1: of democratic illiteral politics, as in the U.S.

Speaker1: And Western Europe, Chinese governments continuously can adapt to domestic and

Speaker1: global market dynamics, as well as increasingly so these days shifting geopolitical conditions.

Speaker1: To fulfill what I see as these multi-pronged missions of promoting economic

Speaker1: growth, maintaining social equity and also stability, and also defending national security.

Speaker1: So this pursuit, I think, is always complicated by the kind of highly fragmented

Speaker1: nature of the Chinese polity as vertically multilayered into various provinces,

Speaker1: municipalities, and also counties.

Speaker1: When I go to, you know, villages, right? So there are kind of several layers of system there.

Speaker1: And also horizontally scattered through different regulatory agencies,

Speaker1: often, you know, competing with each other for bureaucratic power.

Speaker1: So emerging early 2000, because China's evolving, growing involvement in global

Speaker1: financial market, private internet companies like Alibaba,

Speaker1: they presented both opportunity and challenges to the central party state and

Speaker1: its economic dominance, right?

Speaker1: So on the one hand, the state initially really tolerated their growth and, you know, have

Speaker1: Actually sought for a long time to leverage their infrastructure role to facilitate

Speaker1: economic and political restructuring, right?

Speaker1: So there were also scholars writing about this kind of economic nationalism, right, where, you know,

Speaker1: by promoting these indigenous big techs, China was able to drive out through

Speaker1: also the kind of great firewall of China all these other incumbent players from Silicon Valley.

Speaker1: So, but more recently, there has been a shift, right? So in how China wants

Speaker1: to, you know, reposition itself,

Speaker1: Transitioning from like a GDP-centric approach of governance towards emphasizing

Speaker1: domestic consumption, right? Indigenous innovation, environmental sustainability,

Speaker1: and also, in a way, redistribution and public service.

Speaker1: On the other hand, these technology firms'

Speaker1: monopolistic size, infrastructure significance, and relative autonomy from the

Speaker1: state, which I think in Chinese history, if you look back at it,

Speaker1: has never happened before in such powerful companies.

Speaker1: Domestic, you know, not foreign colonial ones have kind of disrupted the kind

Speaker1: of equilibrium of China's so-called market in state system,

Speaker1: which is a concept I borrowed from political scientists, Zheng Yongnian and

Speaker1: historian Huang Yanzhi there.

Speaker1: So basically, they're saying that, you know, market is always kind of embedded

Speaker1: into the state. State, oh, in a way, kind of dictates historically in Chinese history, that is.

Speaker1: And these firms, these big tech, their integration into global financial system

Speaker1: and their expanding global reach really present a kind of complex challenges

Speaker1: for the Chinese party state.

Speaker1: It must navigate enhancing the kind of global competitiveness of Chinese businesses

Speaker1: and countries' global influence,

Speaker1: while also at the same time safeguarding state power from dominance of domestic

Speaker1: and international financial interest, right?

Speaker1: So as a result, I think that's how we witnessed the kind of pendulum swing of

Speaker1: central state from a rather laissez-faire approach to big tax up till,

Speaker1: I would say, the mid-2010s.

Speaker1: Two more toughen stunts in the late 2010s and early 2000s, which peaked in the

Speaker1: last minute suspension of Ant Group's IPO in 2020, right?

Speaker1: And also the kind of subsequent big tech crackdown, the drama play out and reported

Speaker1: very well by international media.

Speaker1: However, the state swam back to a softer approach in early 2020,

Speaker1: Trying to really stimulate a stagnant economy, resulting from stringent zero

Speaker1: COVID control, and also a general economic downturn triggered partially by the

Speaker1: kind of collapse of the real estate market.

Speaker1: Right. So in the process, we also witnessed how Alibaba has tried to really

Speaker1: pivot towards a so-called state-designated strategic industries like artificial

Speaker1: intelligence is kind of doing very well in that regard and also making chips.

Speaker1: So that is, I think, help us to understand the kind of constant adjustments

Speaker1: and stay firm relation at the central level.

Speaker1: But Alibaba has also been very kind of dexterous at navigating China's intricate

Speaker1: and multilayer local government regime

Speaker1: to not only clear barriers, but also in a way mobilize local government support

Speaker1: for its market expansion.

Speaker1: So despite the central state new priorities, local officials continue to see

Speaker1: economic growth and the local employment generation as their priorities.

Speaker1: At the same time, they also have to adapt to the central government's ever-shifting

Speaker1: cadre evaluation standards in a kind of a landness system. I think that would

Speaker1: still characterize the Chinese bureaucratic system at this moment.

Speaker1: Which often demand local governments to really support and advance central government

Speaker1: new policy initiatives.

Speaker1: So in my field work, for example, I found that in the 2010s,

Speaker1: when promoting e-commerce and mass entrepreneurship and innovation,

Speaker1: Even in the Chinese countryside was a central priority.

Speaker1: Local governments actually competed with each other, different kind of county-level

Speaker1: provincial governments to work with big tech firms like Alibaba and Tencent.

Speaker1: For example, in the case of Alibaba e-commerce, they subsidized local last mile

Speaker1: logistic networks and also constructed

Speaker1: model village e-commerce entrepreneurs, like what they did in the socialist

Speaker1: era, in the Maoist era, the so-called model social workers, right?

Speaker1: Now we have model Alibaba or e-commerce entrepreneurs.

Speaker1: So it's both kind of symbolic, cultural, and also economic.

Speaker1: And in this light, local governments may appear more like towing the central

Speaker1: party line, but in reality, corruption and local improvisation were prevalent.

Speaker1: And in this paper, specifically, I told the story of how local municipal government

Speaker1: misused actually provincial funds

Speaker1: earmarked for e-commerce and poverty reduction in the countryside to develop

Speaker1: residential buildings and e-commerce office spaces that village entrepreneurs had no use for, right?

Speaker1: So you'll also see that kind of discrepancy there, fragmentation there.

Speaker1: However, after the big tech crackdown in early 2020s, local state actually became

Speaker1: more cautious when collaborating with big tech firms like Alibaba

Speaker1: And sometimes actually would prefer to actually collaborate with local state-owned or

Speaker1: private sometimes companies to work on new digital

Speaker1: projects, including the kind of new

Speaker1: research I've been looking at, the building rural digital brains, for example.

Speaker1: They prefer to work with provincial or local municipal city-based private firms.

Speaker1: So that is to say, unlike in the Western, especially I would say American context,

Speaker1: in which commercial and private business interests are pretty dominant in the

Speaker1: entanglement between politics and commons, right?

Speaker1: So it's not to say that commons and politics or state and market are separated in the U.S. context.

Speaker1: But I think the Chinese market, in the Chinese case, the market is often subordinated

Speaker1: to the political demands of central states.

Speaker1: And the power of private business in China is both enabled, as we have witnessed

Speaker1: on different levels, but also constrained by the central authority.

Speaker1: But domination is not absolute, and state always has to constantly seek a balance

Speaker1: between economic growth and political stability and control,

Speaker1: leading to the cycles that we saw.

Speaker1: You know, that's why temporality matters in that regard in understanding the dynamics.

Speaker1: And there are also plenty of spaces resulted from central local states discrepancy,

Speaker1: as I mentioned, for private firms like Alibaba to carefully navigate in this case.

Speaker1: Right. So I think all of these help to complicate the kind of way I think is

Speaker1: simplified narrative of authoritarianism versus neoliberalism when it comes

Speaker1: to big tech governance in China.

Speaker2: Thank you very much. That's extremely insightful. I can recommend these papers

Speaker2: to everyone to read because I think many people will not know this,

Speaker2: especially the state platform co-evolutionary dynamics that you just described.

Speaker2: So maybe two quick questions with quick answers, because we don't have that much time left, I guess.

Speaker2: Where do you see the relationship is heading now? And second, how would you say does

Speaker2: intensifying U.S.-China geopolitical tensions or competition shape these trade-offs?

Speaker1: Very good question. I think we...

Speaker1: Globally, we are in a different time now.

Speaker1: I feel like a decade ago, over the years, the bunch of us have been arguing,

Speaker1: a lot of us actually, for the role of state.

Speaker1: But now I feel like even in the U.S. context, it just has been always a kind

Speaker1: of market-driven space, right, as state becomes more prominent.

Speaker1: And sometimes I feel like the U.S. is trying to learn from China's practices,

Speaker1: right? So in the rise of industrial policies and all that.

Speaker1: So I do feel like we are in a different time.

Speaker1: And also, I think the Chinese

Speaker1: Big tech firms, right? And because of how in the Chinese term,

Speaker1: there is a term called evolution.

Speaker1: Which basically means how competitive in a way, right?

Speaker1: So because of the kind of local government dynamics, right? So each local government

Speaker1: would support their own tempings in a way, right? And then we also have this

Speaker1: kind of national firms like Alibaba and Tencent and all that, TikTok, for example.

Speaker1: And because of how competitive it is, although China has a big market,

Speaker1: they are also kind of expanding overseas to other parts of the world, including

Speaker1: Europe, and trying to kind of really making euros into the European market,

Speaker1: but also global south, right?

Speaker1: And so I do see, you know, China at this moment

Speaker1: Is also evolving, right? Whether it would become more state capitalist, I don't know.

Speaker1: Whether some of the kind of dynamics observed in the Chinese context,

Speaker1: in the domestic context, that I would say is more kind of socialist in a way,

Speaker1: would also be mapped out into the

Speaker1: into the expanding dynamics overseas, right? So that's something I think I'm

Speaker1: really observing at this moment.

Speaker1: And I see, you know, scholars working in this so-called space of global China,

Speaker1: myself included with my new projects.

Speaker1: And so I think there are interesting dynamics and I think historical past dependencies

Speaker1: still matter, I would say.

Speaker1: But I think in different contexts, you know, it played out differently.

Speaker1: And I don't have a conclusive answer to that question yet, but it's definitely

Speaker1: changing with all the different dynamics. You know, how the world is changing,

Speaker1: how China is kind of repositioning itself, right? As a kind of expanding industrial technological power.

Speaker2: That's very insightful. Thank you.

Speaker0: And you mentioned,

Speaker0: these changing global dynamics as one topic that interests you and that you're

Speaker0: working on at the moment.

Speaker0: And you also said that you have a few more projects. And as we are opening with,

Speaker0: the same question, we're also closing our conversations with the same question.

Speaker0: And the closing question always is, what are you working on right now? What's coming next?

Speaker1: What's top of your mind?

Speaker1: Yeah, right. So one of my current projects, one is more domestic driven,

Speaker1: actually looks like at how AI is transforming agriculture and rural life, which I think is

Speaker1: an area that's often overlooked in the broader conversation about AI at this moment.

Speaker1: It's a lot about AI, which also builds on my early work about platforms and digital labor.

Speaker1: And I examine how data and algorithms are reshaping farming,

Speaker1: governance, and everyday life in the Chinese context.

Speaker1: Since 2024, I've been doing fieldwork, attending to kind of agri-tech events

Speaker1: and interview farmers, officials, and engineers.

Speaker1: A recent paper I co-authored with my colleague Tu Lan at UNH,

Speaker1: which is forthcoming from Big Data Society, we try to really develop the idea of so-called

Speaker1: data fix to explain how digital infrastructures are used to manage economic

Speaker1: and social tensions, actually using China's agriculture digital brain,

Speaker1: the case I mentioned previously.

Speaker1: And we try to really connect this to the kind of global debates about data power and inequalities

Speaker1: And I've also been trying to branch beyond platform studies to find a mental

Speaker1: space outside of that to look at China's global rise through biotech.

Speaker1: And so this is my new book project, tentatively titled Circulating Innovation,

Speaker1: Where I trace how knowledge, talent, capital, and policy move across major hubs

Speaker1: from Boston to Shanghai to Hong Kong, Shenzhen, and also Chengdu,

Speaker1: where it's in West China,

Speaker1: and also increasingly into places like Southeast Asia, right?

Speaker1: So the project's basically trying to set up a kind of three-part narrative that

Speaker1: starts with the kind of often overlooked role of Chinese immigrant scientists in building U.S.

Speaker1: Biotech industry from Boston, and look at China's own rise since the 2000s,

Speaker1: which was actually driven a lot by these kind of returnee scientists with state support.

Speaker1: And finally, examines how the Chinese biotech firms are now expanding globally.

Speaker1: We hear a lot about these kind of transporter deals, you know,

Speaker1: navigating both geopolitical tensions and new opportunities in both the global

Speaker1: south and global now, right? Building all kinds of...

Speaker1: Initiatives and setting med tech

Speaker1: Into Indonesia, for example. So I think these two lines of research certainly

Speaker1: keeps me busy at this moment.

Speaker1: But I'm trying to also build up a new research area outside of the platform

Speaker1: at this moment, which is very challenging, as you can imagine.

Speaker0: Yeah, there's also a little bit of past dependency at place.

Speaker0: Yeah for sure yeah that sounds super exciting um i can't wait to to read more of or to read about the,

Speaker0: the upcoming read your upcoming publications and and,

Speaker0: know more about the upcoming work that you just described um and with that thank

Speaker0: you so much then for for sharing these very very rich insights from your years and years,

Speaker0: of research on site, really, on the ground,

Speaker0: in China and elsewhere, and sharing this with us and our listeners. Thank you so much.

Speaker1: Thank you so much for the opportunity to share my research.

Speaker2: Thank you so much, Lin. It was super interesting and super insightful.

New comment

Your name or nickname, will be shown publicly
At least 10 characters long
By submitting your comment you agree that the content of the field "Name or nickname" will be stored and shown publicly next to your comment. Using your real name is optional.